You’ve got to love a bad Shakespeare reference. Or, not.
I’m fascinated by how people talk about paying down debt – some refer to it as “debt reduction,” and others use language like, “debt eradication,” or “debt elimination.”
Personally, as mindsets go, I’m with that second group. To me, debt reduction is something that you’re doing on the way to achieving a goal of debt elimination. I don’t really understand why anyone would stop at reducing their debt. Yes, I am biased. But, if reducing debt is your end goal, isn’t that like going on a diet by skipping dinner and eating a cheesecake?
One thing’s for sure – whether you’ve decided to go relocate to DebtFree land, or just be a tourist there, having a plan is critical.
One of the best – and most blogged about – strategies for getting rid of debt is the debt snowball, a term that originates with Dave Ramsey and that has been adopted and adapted by any number of personal finance gurus. My personal favourite adaptation is the Debt Avalanche, which brings together the rational financial practicality of the “traditional” debt snowball; and the psychological warm fuzzy of Dave Ramsey’s more immediately gratifying approach.
(Note: This is my overview of the three methods of snowballing debt – if you want to read another take (or 20!), try googling “debt snowball,” “debt avalanche,” “dave ramsey,” or read the archives of just about anyone on the $M blogroll.)
The basic process is the same across these methods – the difference is in the details. All three variations have these steps in common:
1. you need to make a date with your budget and determine some important information:
- what is your minimum monthly payment for each debt
- how much additional money can you pull out of the budget to assign to additional debt repayment
- what are the amounts and interest rates of your various debts
2. each month, you pay the minimum payment on all of your debts, and take the additional money that you found in your budget and use it to pay an additional amount on one debt (how you choose this is what makes the difference between the methods).
3. you continue to make this minimum+extra payment on the debt until it is gone. Then you take that amount (debt 1 minimum + original extra amount) and call it the “new extra amount” (or whatever floats your boat)
4. the new extra amount is added to the minimum payment for debt 2 until it is gone. Then you repeat steps 2 & 3, adding the ever-increasing “extra” amount to minimum payments on subsequent debts until all of your debt is repaid.
Because you’re servicing all of your debts, the impact on your credit score is positive; because you’re repaying debt more quickly than by making only minimum payments, the impact on your personal financial bottom line is also positive.
If you had the following three debts that you wanted to erradicate:
credit card – $18000 @ 12%
student loan - $15000 @ 6.5%
mortgage - $150000 @ 5.25%
How do you know where to start? This is the distinction between the three methods
|
Debt Snowball (Ramsey) |
Debt is put in order from smallest amount to largest amount, so Dave would have you paying the student loan first, and the mortgage last. |
|
Highest Interest Variation |
Debt is ordered from highest- to lowest interest rate. First to go will be the credit card @ 18%, then the student loan, and then the mortgage. |
|
Debt Avalanche |
First, you pay the smallest debt, then, once you’ve got a feeling of accomplishment and some momentum, you pay the debts in order of declining interest rate. So, in this case, student loan, then credit card, then mortgage (just like Dave’s way in this case, but for a different reason). |
Really, what it comes down to is what criteria you choose for prioritizing your debt. All three of these methods work, the differences between them are (relatively) minimal. Ramsey’s is favoured by people who want the psychological benefits of seeing progress in debt reduction by reducing the number of debts. People who favour the highest-interest version are most concerned with the total cost of the debt – the less interest you pay, the better. The Debt Avalanche is trying to capture the logic of both of these approaches by first giving you a push in the form of eliminating a debt, then giving you the benefit of reduced cost of the debt. Which is better? As always, that depends on what your priorities are.
Probably the most interesting commentary I’ve seen on this issue in a long time came in the form of a comment on the original Debt Avalanche posting on Consumerism Commentary back in July. Troy, commenter # 29 offers a compelling argument for another criteria for prioritizing your debt: risk. Take a look:
No one ever give risk enough weight. Not paying off revolving debt carries risk. Juggling several debts carries risk. All debt carries risk. The interest rate is A factor, not THE factor. Balance is A factor. Risk is also a factor. Risk of rate changes, universal default, etc.
The best way to eliminate debt is to pay off the RISKIEST debt first. Sometimes it is the one with the highest payment, sometimes the highest interest rate, sometimes the highest balance.
You must also consider life situations. If you are trying to reduce your debts to qualify for a better rate on your new home purchase, lenders care about your MONTHLY debt obligations, not your TOTAL outstanding debt. Paying off a low interest (5%) car loan with a $700 monthly payment will make a much larger impact than eliminating a 20% $4,000 credit card balance. If that car payoff gets you a .25% better interest rate on a $200,000 mortgage, it is “mathematically superior” to pay attention to your own situation and pay of the loans with RISK.
So, while the idea of making inflated payments on your debts, one debt at a time is an excellent one for (relatively) quickly getting rid of debt; there really is no such thing as a solution that is the “best” strategy for everyone (despite Troy’s assurances!). No surprises there – you have to make these decisions based on your situation, and your needs. As those change, so will your plan.
Have a safe trip to DebtFree land! See you there!
